By Stephanie Elliott, Museum Curator
So what similaries do television shows like Antinques Roadshow, American Pickers, and Hardcore Pawn have with people who work with museum collections? Not a whole lot, but in my opinion they tend to give people a false idea of what a museum curator does. It can be difficult at times when someone brings in an item they found in their grandmother’s attic, or dug up on the side of the road, that they believe is very old and very valuable, to then tell them that it is not exactly what they think it is.
Because museum curators or collection staff are not trained in antique appraisals we cannot give anyone a monetary value of their object. We can research the history of the object and tell them more about it, but that is it. We also do not know exactly what every item is that is brought into the museum. That is one of the things that shows like Antinques Roadshow does not portray is the amount of research that goes into identifying and appraising an object. You also don’t see the hundreds or thousands of items that are brought in that are worth nothing.
It is sometimes difficult trying to let someone down easy when they think they really have something of value. For example, I have had many people bring in what they believe is an original copy of the Declaration of Independence and I have to tell them that it is actually a replica produced in 1976 for the 200th anniversary. I have had people call me a liar and tell me I have no idea what I’m talking about, and in those cases I just have to let it go. I have also had people offer to split whatever profit they make from an item if I just gave them a “ballpark” as to how much it is worth.
I’m not saying that we don’t love for people to bring items into the museum so that we can look at them and hopefully tell them more about the object, but sometimes people have a misconception about what we can and cannot do that can make it difficult at times. One of the most interesting aspects of my job is learning about new objects, where they come from, and the history surrounding them. It can just be challenging at times when shows on TV make it seem like everything is a hidden treasure, when that usually isn’t reality.